"Ms. McNeely, pray define magic in the context you write it in? Are Potions not "magic"? Please also team up with Ms. Cotgrave to convince me why a charm cannot change the texture of an object. 6 points to Slytherin."
"Ms... Lestrange, I'm assuming. Please check your quill, it doesn't seem to know how to spell your name. I see a distinct lack of living things being charmed in your paper. Please research on the difference between an object and a human succumbing to a charm. 5 points to Ravenclaw."
"Ms. Valencia, your quill seems to be in on the conspiracy too. At least, I don't remember asking about "char". Please elaborate on your "physical form" comment. Seeing as charms have been known to both increase and decrease the weight/mass of an object. 7 points to Gryffindor."
Having finished, the man addressed the students at large. "From all of your answers, I can see that you've not grasped the basic theory of magic. What is Magic, where does it come from? Why can we manipulate it and not the Muggles? These are all questions you should know the answer to by now seeing as it's impossible to progress without knowing."
Flicking his wand casually to the blackboard, the wizards pointed behind his head to the sheet that now hung there.
"As you can see, it was Merlin who first suggested that Magic exists in the environment, meaning, there is an unending supply of it around us. He later theorized that wizards and witches were born with the inherent ability to detect that magic. The theory was later amended to include certain types of flora and fauna as well."
"Asbastoff however, directly opposed Merlin and held that there is no such thing as Magic in the environment. That certain creatures are simply born as a result of genetic mutations and can therefore control their surroundings through a purely mental process yet largely untapped," he continued. He had no doubt more than one head would be drooping all too close to the desk at the end of class but it was better to get the tedious fundamentals out of the way first.
"Merlin's theory is the one that holds most stock these days though that doesn't mean Asbastoff was wrong. Now, keeping these two views in mind, can anyone tell me the flaw in both these theories?"
"And those still working on their papers, please listen to the class discussion for a while. You can hand in your work at the end," he added as an afterthought.
Last edited by Tristyn Malfoy on Sat 14 Aug 2010, 18:02; edited 1 time in total